A paired thinking-partner prompt set. The Hard Mirror finds the broken joint in your plan across six labeled passes. Argue The Other Side stress-tests anything you just wrote.
Before you start
You'll want a working sense of how to brief Claude with real context before deploying The Hard Mirror; the persona only works if you bring it something specific to attack. Bring a plan, a draft, or a decision, not a vague idea.
Paste this once at the top of a fresh Claude conversation to lock the role for the whole session. Every reply that follows runs the six passes in order. If Claude opens with 'great plan' or 'I love this,' re-paste; the persona drifted.
The persona is only as sharp as what you feed it. 'Should I quit my job' is too vague. 'I am thinking of leaving my current role in 6 weeks to take a smaller offer at a startup; here is the comp, here is what I am giving up, here is the unknown' is something The Hard Mirror can actually attack.
Use this after The Hard Mirror, or standalone on any draft (essay, pitch, strategy doc). It returns three ordered outputs: weakest claims (with quotes), the best counter-case made strongly, and what survives the attack. The 'what survives' line is AL's addition; the source only tears down, which leaves you with no signal on what to keep.
The Hard Mirror earns its setup cost on recurring use, not one-shot sessions. Pick the decision or plan you are most tempted to avoid and run it through once a week. Adjust the plan based on the kill-switch line. Skip a week and you regress to default agreeable Claude.