The same questions and one scoring guide for every candidate
Two candidates interview for the same crew lead job. One is asked about equipment and safety, and the other is asked about weekends and family. Both are scored on 'gut feel'.
18 min · You'll build interview questions and a 1-3-5 scoring guide from dutiesYou'll build five questions, each tied to a duty, with a 1, 3 and 5 answer guide. You'll also leave out the questions you must not ask.
Step 1 of 6: The idea
Step 1 of 6
The one idea this lesson is about, and why it matters.
Complete Write a job description that is accurate and fair first. This lesson starts from a duties list like the one you wrote there.
Quick recall · Where AI helps in HR work, and where it must not decide
Back to your sort from lesson 1. Interviewing sits near two of your colors: building the questions and scoring the candidates. Which color is each, what keeps them apart, and which of those two jobs are you doing in your own next interview?
Building the question bank is green: it is a document you read and own, with no candidate details. Scoring and deciding about candidates is red: a person does it, from their own notes. What keeps them apart is who decides and what information goes in. Your own next interview should use both: the bank is built with the tool, and the scoring is yours.
Ask every candidate the same job-related questions, and score each answer against one guide written before the first interview. That is a structured interview: the same questions in the same order, rated on one scale (US Office of Personnel Management, OPM). A chat tool can build the bank in minutes.
A 2023 review by Sackett and colleagues put the validity of structured interviews at about .42, and of unstructured ones at about .19. Validity here means how closely scores track how people later do the job, where 0 is no link and 1 is a perfect one. The likely range around .42 runs from .18 to .66, so a structured interview helps but guarantees nothing.
What AI does and what you do. The tool drafts questions and a scoring guide from your duties list. A person asks, listens, takes notes and scores.
AI does not score people (lesson 1), and no candidate's name, resume or answers go into the chat.
Build the bank from your duties. Write one question for each core duty, as in lesson 3. Ask each for a past situation ("Tell me about a time..."), because past behavior is something you can compare across candidates.
The scoring guide. For each question, describe what a 1, a 3 and a 5 answer sounds like, in things a person did and not traits. These descriptions are called anchors.
"Stopped the work, explained why and checked later" is something you can score. "Seems like a natural leader" is not.
Write the guide before the first interview, and use the same sheet for every candidate. After each interview, score from your notes before you talk with the other interviewers. A one-line reason for each score helps you explain it later.
Questions to leave out. The EEOC says employers may not ask about disability before an offer, and requests should be limited to what is essential to judge qualifications. So do not ask "Do you have any health conditions?"
Ask about the job instead: "This job requires lifting up to 50 pounds, with or without reasonable accommodation. Can you perform these duties?" The ADA regulation allows questions about the ability to do job-related functions.
Questions about age, family plans, religion, race, national origin or where someone is "really from" have no job reason. They can also be used as evidence of bias, so skip them. If you are unsure, ask your counsel (an employment lawyer, and lesson 1 says how to find one).
Criminal-history and pay-history questions are covered by rules that vary by state and city, and the tool does not know yours. Leave them out until you have checked (search "[your state] labor department" plus the topic). Read the EEOC's small-business guide on criminal records (eeoc.gov/employers/small-business/criminal-records), which covers weighing a record against the job.
Keep the paper. The federal rule is to keep personnel records, including hiring records, for one year from the record or the action. Personnel records are the files you hold about hiring and managing a person, and your interview notes and score sheets count.
Your state may require longer, so search "[your state] labor department record retention" (the address usually ends in .gov) or ask your counsel. This is training, not legal advice.
Below, the owner of Rivera Landscaping, a 40-person company, builds a bank for a crew lead. Build from the duties, score with a guide written first, and keep the paper.
That is the idea. Next you watch it work.
Step 2 of 6
See one real prompt do one real job, then see which part of it made that work.
You type this
Build an interview question bank for a Crew Lead at Rivera Landscaping, a 40-person landscaping company. Use only the duties and needs below. Duties: - Lead a crew of 3 to 5 on residential jobs and keep the day on schedule - Run daily safety talks and make sure crew members use protective gear - Check and care for mowers, trimmers and trucks, and report problems the same day - Handle customer questions or complaints at the job site - Fill in daily job sheets with hours and materials Needs of the job, with or without reasonable accommodation: lift up to 50 pounds, and work outdoors in heat and rain. Write 5 questions, one per duty, in that order. Each should ask for a past situation. For each, say what a 1, 3 and 5 answer sounds like, in things the candidate did and not traits. Add one standard ability question about the needs of the job. Do not ask about health, age, family, or anything not tied to a duty. Add one opening line the interviewer reads to every candidate.
Your AI tool does this
Your AI tool goes next.
Step 3 of 6
Write one part of the prompt yourself, then compare with one good answer.
What the anchors should describe
Think about what two different interviewers could both see and agree on.
Your answer is saved with your progress, so leave out anything private.
Try it before you go on.
Getting it wrong first is what makes it stick.
Step 4 of 6
Do the task on your own work, in your own tool.
Build a bank from your own duties list, with an ability question and an opening line. Check each question against its duty, cut any you cannot tie to one, and copy the result onto the scoring sheet.
Go do it for real.
Come back with a result.
Leave out anything private. This uses one of your Course Council messages.
Step 5 of 6
Fill in your own card, then save it to your workbook.
Your takeaway
Loading your card…
Save your card before you go on. It goes in your workbook.
Step 6 of 6
Say it from memory first, then check it.
Pulling this out of your own head now is the part that actually moves it into long-term memory. Re-reading only feels like it does.
Without scrolling up, say what makes an interview structured, and name the part of interviewing that stays with a person. Then say which topic you have asked about in an interview that you will now leave out.
Structured means the same job-related questions, in the same order, scored on one scale against a guide written first. The person asks, listens, notes and scores, and the tool never sees a candidate. For your topic, a good answer names it and the job question you will ask in its place.
Build the bank. You can build a question bank from a duties list, one question per core duty.
Build the bank from the job's duties, write the 1-3-5 guide before the first interview, and use the same questions and sheet for everyone. A person asks, notes and scores.
Hand the tool the checking, not the judging: list each of these questions beside the duty it tests. Then ask it to flag any with no duty, or any that asks about health, age, family, religion, race, national origin, criminal history or pay history. You decide what stays.
That is the lesson. Mark it complete, and its question comes back to you in three days.